Answer the following questions and respond to two of your classmates comments.
1. List 3 specific laws that you would want if you were stranded on an island with your classmates. (example: no killing)
2. How would you enforce these laws?
3. Which example of laws do your rules follow?
A. Law as Power
B. Natural Law
C. Utilitarian Law
D. Historical Jurisprudence
4. Do you believe that this would work? Why or Why not?
1.
ReplyDeletea) Do not kill (Natural)
b) The Golden Rule (Natural)
c) Protect each other (Natural)
2. Punishments for those who do not follow the rules
3. Listed above.
4. Yes I do because no one would want to get killed or left behind, so I would hope they wouldn't do that to others.
I agree with the Golden Rule lol:)
DeleteThat's a good way to put it.
Delete1. A- No killing will not be tolerated (Natural Law)
ReplyDeleteB- Respect each other (Natural Law)
C- Everyone must pay taxes (Historical Jurisprudence)
2. -Punishment for those who disobey you will be kicked off the island.
3. A- Natural Law
B- Natural Law
C- Historical Jurisprudence
4- I believe this rules would work, i think people would fear being kicked off the island thus following the rules, And these rules would maximize everyone's pleasure.
I like the fact that we both agree on the punishment, where they get kicked off the island
Delete1.
ReplyDeleteA) Do not kill (natural law)
B) Respect (natural law)
C) Everyone is created equal (natural law)
2. Punishment would be who ever doesn't follow the rules they will be either killed or booted off the island.
3.
A) Natural
B) Natural
C) Natural
4. I believe that it will work because they know their consequences and if they fail to follow the rules something bad will happen depending on how bad the situation was.
I agree with you.
Deletei feel this could work but have more than two definite responses to disobedience of the laws
DeleteI like the booted off the island thing, its a little harsh but i understand it. :)
DeleteI agree with those laws.
Delete1. A. No murder or killing
ReplyDeleteB. No stealing from others
C. Equality for others.
2. I would enforce these laws with a harsh punishment so that ev eryone will follow the laws and elimates others from trying to break laws.
3. A. Natural law
B. Natural law
C. Natural law
4. I believe this will work because its fair and equal for everyone and its almost a cmmon law from birth.
i agree with your laws
DeleteI like your laws, they're morals that everyone should have.
DeleteI agree with all of your laws.
Delete1.no harm to fellow citizens
ReplyDeletehelp to get help
every one or no one
2. how these laws would be enforced is if they killed or harmed then they would have the same happen to them if they didn't help they they were caged 1 day for every thing they didn't held with if you are selfish then every thing gets taken away from you and distributed to every one else.
3 natural
natural
natural
4. to an extent it will work but till that point i view this will work and its easy to follow.but to the end i don't think it will last long
1.
ReplyDeleteA. Do not kill
B. Treat everyone the same
C. Equal Work
2. If no one follows the laws, they well be punished by not being able to eat.
3.
A. Natural
B. Natural
C. Utilitarian
4. I know it well work. People are going to want to eat and they can't unless they follow the rules.
C.
1. -no killing
ReplyDelete-treat everyone as you would want to be treated
-everyone works together as a community
2. If someone disobeyed one of the rules, there would be consequences. Such as if you killed someone you would be banished to the other side of the island. If they mistreated someone or got in a fight with them they would have to apologize and make up with that person. Lastly if you weren't working well with the group then you would have more chores to do, and have to place a bigger effort on working with others.
3. natural law
natural law
natural law
4. Yes, because its natural, its the right thing to do. Well I think most people would feel this is right.